By Darryl Jacobs ESPN/CBS Sports Networks
Commentator/Analyst
The NFL offseason is a thrilling spectacle, always filled with high-stakes drama.
Few positions ignite more intrigue than quarterback, and the 2025 free agency period has been a whirlwind of movement, with veteran signal-callers trading jerseys at an unprecedented rate. And at the heart of this captivating narrative?
Russell Wilson is now the starting quarterback for the New York Giants—his third team in three seasons, a testament to the unpredictable nature of the quarterback position.
Once regarded as one of the league’s most reliable and dynamic quarterbacks, Wilson’s journey over the last three years has been a rollercoaster of highs and lows. Now, in the biggest media market, he gets what might be his final chance to prove he still belongs among the NFL’s elite.
But in an era where quarterbacks are treated as interchangeable chess pieces, is Wilson the answer for the Giants, or just another short-term stopgap in their never-ending search for stability?
QB Carousel: Wilson’s Journey
Just three years ago, Wilson was still viewed as a top-tier quarterback, coming off a decade of success with the Seattle Seahawks. His Super Bowl victory, nine Pro Bowl appearances, and reputation as a leader made him one of the league’s most respected stars. But then, the ride took an unexpected turn.
- Denver Broncos (2022–2023): The Broncos went all-in on Wilson, trading multiple first-round picks and signing him to a massive $245 million contract. The expectation was Super Bowl contention; the reality was a complete disaster. Wilson struggled to adapt, the offense stagnated, and after two seasons, Denver moved on, cutting their losses in one of the worst trades in NFL history.
- Pittsburgh Steelers (2024): Looking for a fresh start, Wilson signed with the Steelers on a low-risk, one-year deal. While he showed flashes of his former self, Pittsburgh remained non-committal, opting to develop a younger quarterback instead of investing in Wilson long-term.
- New York Giants (2025–?): Wilson arrives in New York—a city and a franchise starving for a winning football team and a reliable quarterback for years.
Why the Giants Chose Wilson Over Other Free Agents
This off-season’s quarterback free agency market was one of the most active in recent memory. Kirk Cousins, Justin Fields, and even Aaron Rodgers were high-profile names. Having grown frustrated with Daniel Jones’ inconsistency and injuries, the Giants had a choice to make.
Many speculated that Rodgers, after an injury-plagued stint with the Jets, could jump across town to the Giants. Instead, the team opted for Wilson—a decision that raised eyebrows but made more sense when examined closely.
- Mobility and Playmaking Ability – Unlike Rodgers, who thrives within structure but is coming off an Achilles injury, Wilson still possesses enough athleticism to extend plays and create opportunities when things break down. With the Giants’ offensive line still a work in progress, mobility was a key factor in their decision.
- Proven Leadership and Stability – Wilson remains one of the league’s most respected voices despite his recent struggles. The Giants, with a young core, see his veteran presence as a potential game-changer, providing the leadership necessary to elevate the team and bring stability to the franchise. This should fill Giants fans with hope and optimism for the future.
- Brian Daboll’s Offense /Right Fit—The Giants’ coaching staff had a clear vision for their offense and wanted a quarterback who could execute that vision. Wilson, with his experience running RPOs (run-pass options) and improvisational skills, was seen as a better fit than Rodgers or other options, aligning more closely with the team’s offensive strategy.
- The Giants’ Complicated History with Black Quarterbacks – Beyond football, Wilson’s signing carries profound significance. The New York Giants, one of the NFL’s most storied franchises, have historically overlooked Black quarterbacks. Before 2017, no African American quarterback had ever started a game for the team, a stark contrast to the NFL’s evolution. Wilson’s presence symbolizes a progressive shift in an organization that, for years, was behind the curve in embracing diversity at sport’s most important position. This change should make all fans feel included and hopeful for a more diverse future at the position.
Wilson, now the most accomplished Black quarterback to ever wear a Giants uniform, is breaking barriers in a way that goes beyond just winning games. His presence symbolizes change in an organization that, for years, was behind the curve in embracing diversity at the sport’s most important position.
The Stakes Are Higher Than Ever
Signing Wilson is a calculated risk for the Giants. At 36 years old, he is no longer in his prime, and his recent struggles have raised legitimate concerns. But Wilson’s career has been built on defying expectations, silencing doubters, and proving people wrong.
For the Giants, this move is about more than just 2025. It’s about finally bringing stability to a franchise stuck in a cycle of mediocrity. If Wilson returns to form, the Giants could quickly become contenders in an NFC that remains wide open. This potential transformation should fill Giants fans with hope and optimism. If he falters, it’s yet another swing-and-miss at the quarterback position, and the search will continue.
The NFL’s quarterback carousel rarely slows down, and for the past three seasons, Wilson has been caught in its relentless spin. But now, in the bright lights of New York, he can do what few expect—step off the ride, take control, and write his own comeback story.
For Wilson, the question isn’t just whether he can still play at a high level. It’s whether he can finally find a place to call home. And for the Giants, the answer to that question could define their future for years and bring hope and excitement to a fanbase that has endured years of disappointment.
